Race, Politics and Indigenous Education
Unsettling the Gap: Race, Politics and Indigenous Education examines pressing issues of inequality in education. The notion of gap—and the need to close it—is used widely in public and policy debates to name the nature and scope of disadvantage. In the competitive world of education, gaps have become associated with students who are seen to be "falling behind," "failing" or "dropping out." A global deficit discourse is, therefore, mobilised and normalised. But this discourse has a history and is deeply political. Unsettling the Gap examines this history and how it is politically activated through an analysis of the "Australian Closing the Gap in Indigenous Disadvantage" policy. In this policy discourse the notion of gap serves as a complex and multiple signifier, attached to individuals, communities and to national history.
In unravelling these diverse modalities of gap, the text illuminates the types of ruling binaries that tend to direct dynamics of power and knowledge in a settler colonial context. This reveals not only the features of the crisis of "Indigenous educational disadvantage" that the policy seeks to address, but the undercurrents of a different type of crisis, namely the authority of the settler colonial state. By unsettling the normalised functions of gap discourse the book urges critical reflections on the problem of settler colonial authority and how it constrains the possibilities of Indigenous educational justice.
Currency depends on your shipping address
- New York, Bern, Berlin, Bruxelles, Oxford, Wien, 2019. XX, 204 pp., 1 b/w ill., 9 color ills.
- About the author(s)/editor(s)
- About the book
- Advance Praise for Unsettling the Gap
- This eBook can be cited
- Table of Contents
- List of Images
- Abbreviations and Terminology
- Chapter 1. A Future with No More Gaps?
- The policy problem: The stubbornness of Indigenous ‘disadvantage’
- Colonisation and education
- Thinking history
- Policy and politics
- A gap
- The politics of naming
- No more gaps?
- Chapter 2. Racing the Gap: Concepts of Race in the (Settler) Colonial World
- Colonialism and race
- Settler colonial theory
- Power and authority
- Racing the gap
- Chapter 3. Questions of Time
- Histories of and in the present: Examining the policy, its history and its political effects
- ‘A historical knowledge of struggles’: The socio-political conditions of the present, the 1960s and the 1930s
- The recent past and the present: A political snapshot
- The late 1960s: A political snapshot
- The late 1930s: A political snapshot
- The past in the present
- Chapter 4. Standing on the Bridge: Critical Encounters with Ethics and Power
- The politics of knowledge
- The archives
- Reflections: June 2013, Melbourne
- The reading
- Reflections: January 2014, Melbourne
- The analysis
- Reflections: May 2014, Vancouver
- Reflections: June 2014, Birmingham
- Reflections: January 2015, Melbourne
- Standing on the bridge
- Chapter 5. Tracing the Gap: Constructions of Deficiency and Potential
- Deficiency and potential: Uplift, upgrade, closing the gap
- The discourse of deficiency
- The coupling of potential to deficiency
- Contestation and rupture: Interrupting the norm
- The logic of elimination: Correction, normalisation and epistemic dispossession
- Chapter 6. Gauging the Gap: Converging Discourses of Measurement and Rank
- The ladder: Hierarchies of capacity
- Measurement and rank as tools used to indicate deficiency and potential
- Questioning the hegemony of measurement
- Colonisation and neoliberalism: Transnational forces of competition and race
- Chapter 7. The Right Side of the Gap: School, Nation, Inclusion, History
- School, nation, inclusion: Justice and equality, racism and prejudice
- National and social cohesion: The tensions of equality
- Inclusion: Whose responsibility, whose choice?
- The right side of history
- The iterative process of repetition of educational inequality
- Chapter 8. Beyond Closing the Gap: Provocations for Thinking Otherwise
- Nation building and disadvantage: Terra nullius and closing the gap
- Failure and deficiency
- History and the present in addressing structural inequalities
- Difference and structural justice
- Settler colonialism, Indigenous education and decolonisation
- Author Biography
- Artist Biographies
- Series index
Chapter 5. Tracing the Gap: Constructions of Deficiency and Potential
| 85 →
· 5 ·
TRACING THE GAP
Constructions of Deficiency and Potential
Image 5.1. Gordon Bennett, untitled, 1989, oil and acrylic on canvas, six panels each 30 × 30 cm. © The Estate of Gordon Bennett. Courtesy The Estate of Gordon Bennett and the Museum of Contemporary Art, Sydney, gift of Doug Hall 1993. Photo: Richard Stringer. ← 85 | 86 →
Investigation of policy and educational debates over time gives insight into the political relationships between those governing and those being governed. This chapter offers an analysis of how state authorities and public and professional debates have constructed the ‘problem’ of Indigenous educational disadvantage in Australia throughout the 20th century and into the present period. This ‘problem’ in Australia is connected to the global flow of ideas, influenced particularly by debates in the United States, the Pacific region and England. Debates across these contexts, throughout history and into the present, have centred on ideas of ‘racial capacity’ and historical discrimination. The ways in which Indigenous and non-Indigenous people are positioned in the discourses generated through these debates enables a greater understanding of the workings of power and the types of challenges that remain when addressing issues of disadvantage in the present. There are two dominant constructions of Indigenous people in the policy discourse of educational disadvantage: as deficient and with potential. These constructions are explored in this chapter, drawing on evidence from archival and current policy documents, to illustrate...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.