Negotiating Texts and Contexts in Contemporary Irish Studies
Introduction Negotiating Texts and Contexts 1
Introduction Negotiating Texts and Contexts One of the strongest criticisms aimed at the project of Jacques Derrida in particular, and indeed at literary and cultural theory in general, is the relativistic and apolitical nature of its epistemological position. Derrida has been seen as a nihilist and a relativist and as someone for whom any- thing goes in terms of ethics and politics. One of the most celebrated examples of this was the Cambridge affair where Derrida’s putative award of an honorary doctorate from Cambridge University became a point of contestation among the fellows of that college, and later among the wider academic community. In a series of flysheets, supporters and critics set out their arguments and among the reasons offered for the non-awarding of this degree, the following were set out: Despite occasional disclaimers, the major preoccupation and effect of his volumi- nous work has been to deny and to dissolve the standards of evidence and argument on which all academic disciplines are based ... What determines us to oppose this award is not just the absurdity of these doctrines but their dismaying implications for all serious academic subjects ... By denying the distinction between fact and fiction, observation and imagination, evidence and prejudice, they make complete nonsense of science, technology and medicine. In politics they deprive the mind of its defences against dangerously irrational ideologies and regimes. (Non Placet Flysheet 1992, 687) I would counter this assertion and in this book I will use many of Derrida’s ideas to demonstrate the...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.