Show Less

The Challenge of Non-Territorial Autonomy

Theory and Practice


Edited By Ephraim Nimni, Alexander Osipov and David Smith

This book explores and evaluates non-territorial autonomy (NTA), an important modality of ethnic and religious diversity management. Whereas multicultural liberal democracies sincerely champion equality and individual human rights, they often have considerable difficulty in accommodating culturally diverse minority communities. In most cases, minority communities do not reside within a compact space, making any territorial representation impossible. This brings into focus modalities of NTA as a possible alternative approach. NTA takes a variety of different forms, such as consociationalism or national cultural autonomy, and also encompasses other forms of representation, such as frameworks for accommodating indigenous peoples, juridical autonomy extended to religious communities, or elements of some models of multiculturalism. Using both theoretical and empirical approaches, and also including the work of legal practitioners, the essays within this volume examine the challenges and possible solutions offered by different NTA models for the effective participation of minorities in public life, addressing issues such as the limits and/or possibilities of implementing NTA models in liberal democracies, the extent to which NTA approaches can serve the goals of European integration and the European minority protection framework, and the possible role of NTA in resolving protracted territorial conflicts.


Show Summary Details
Restricted access

Vadim Poleshchuk Changes in the Concept of National Cultural Autonomy in Estonia


Vadim Poleshchuk1 Changes in the Concept of National Cultural Autonomy in Estonia In recent years international academia has actively studied the 1925 national cultural autonomy law in Estonia, the country that was the first to apply in practice an old idea of the Austro-Marxists. The reintroduction of the cultural autonomy law in once again independent Estonia in 1993 has also drawn much attention. However, there have been almost no attempts to provide a thorough comparative analysis of the 1925 and 1993 acts. Such an analysis demonstrates that the two laws are in fact essentially dif ferent, especially as regards control over minority language education. The Interwar Period: The Example of the German Community According to the 1897 census, which was conducted in the entire Russian empire, in the current territory of Estonia there were about 945,000 inhab- itants. Among them 90.6 per cent were ethnic Estonians, 4.0 per cent – Russians and 3.7 per cent – Germans. After Estonia became an independent country, the percentage of Russians reached in 1922 8.2 per cent, while the percentage of Germans dropped to 1.7 per cent; Jews and Swedes were below 1 per cent (Tiit 2011: 23, 35). 1 The author is grateful to Stuart Sweeney (UK) for his kind assistance. 150 Vadim Poleshchuk The first Estonian Constitution of 1920 guaranteed to national minori- ties the right to found autonomous institutions for the promotion of the interests of their national culture and welfare in so far as these did not run contrary to the...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.

Do you have any questions? Contact us.

Or login to access all content.