From Hans Pfitzner to Anton Webern
The composers selected for their relevance in Lieder composition during this time illustrate not only the diversity of their musical thought but also a changing approach to the relationship between the poetic text and its musical counterpart. Hans Pfitzner represents the determination to maintain established tradition; subsequently, a chronological progression through the individuality of Paul Hindemith and social integrity of Hanns Eisler leads to the point where transformation of the genre can be said to have begun, with Arnold Schönberg. With the Lieder of Alban Berg and Anton Webern, the genre arrived at a point of convergence with the ideals of German modernism. This study offers new insights into the cultural significance of German songwriting in the first part of the twentieth century.
Chapter 8: Arnold Schönberg: Re-thinking Musical Interpretation of the Poetic Text
Arnold Schönberg: Re-thinking Musical Interpretation of the Poetic Text
Schönberg was, unquestionably, an original thinker. He had vision and courage – even arrogance – which enabled him to pursue his musical instinct, despite frequent hostile criticism of his redefinition of harmony and tonality. First performances of his compositions were notoriously controversial and, although respect for his music has grown, his musical legacy still provokes reactions either of admiration or of rejection, but never indifference.
A relatively recent article in The Guardian discussed the hostility towards the first performance of Schönberg’s second string quartet at a concert in Vienna on 21 December 1908:
Initially, the audience was taken aback by the music’s restraint – ‘the first movement went tolerably’, wrote one critic – but the second movement was a different matter. Any sense of harmonic security quickly evaporated, and when Schoenberg briefly quoted the nursery rhyme tune ‘Ach, du lieber Augustin’, its homely familiarity emphasised the strangeness of its new musical setting. During a pause in the music someone sneezed, provoking howls of laughter that temporarily drowned out the instruments. Things got worse in the last two movements. Breaking with 150 years of musical tradition, Schoenberg had decided to add a soprano to the two violins, viola and cello that normally constitute a string quartet. The soprano had been silent for the first two movements of the piece, but as soon as she began to sing in the third movement people started...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.