Implications for Users of Financial Statements
6 Analysis of investors’ judgments and investment decisions
6.1 Methodological approach 6.1.1 Preliminary considerations In the previous chapter, archival data was used to examine the implications of fair value accounting on properties of financial analysts’ forecasts. This approach is viewed as ade- quate because analysts’ forecasts are easily observable and can therefore be used for empiri- cal research. However, when doing archival research, problems could emerge in circum- stances when archival data cannot easily be obtained from databases or other sources such as annual reports or when data cannot be collected. In addition, another disadvantage of archival research is that the effect of an independent variable cannot be isolated from oth- er factors. In many circumstances it might also be the case that archival data is created for a special purpose, such as various political, legal, or financial reasons other than for the intended analysis and does not provide the exact information needed (Wang (2010), p. 31). Therefore, when examining the implications of fair value measures on investors’ judgments and investment decisions, an archival-based approach seems not to be appro- priate as the behavior of investors cannot easily be observed. For this reason, an experi- mental-based approach is used in order to examine investors’ behavior when confronted with fair value measures. A major advantage of doing experimental-based research is that it allows making causal statements in a way that a circumstance caused a change in behavior (Martin (2000), p. 26). Experiments are research studies in which the variance of all, or nearly all, of the pos- sible influential...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.