Modules for History Lessons
Edited By Uta Fenske, Daniel Groth, Klaus-Michael Guse and Bärbel P. Kuhn
Who Owns the Polish Past? Polish History Seen From Western European and Polish Points of View
Introduction to the Module
The module focuses on the analysis of a newspaper article. In this article from 11 July 2003, the Polish journalist and publicist Adam Krzemiński (born 1945) criticizes the paternalist posture of Western Europeans towards the candidates for joining the EU and compares this posture with the ignorant and imperial attitude of Western Europe towards the eastern half of the continent since the Enlightenment.
In doing so, the author reacts to an initiative of Western European intellectuals led by Jürgen Habermas (born 1929) and Adolf Muschg (born 1934) to form a peace-movement avant-garde of the “old” “Core Europe”. Their motive lay in the Polish participation in the US war with Iraq in 2003. Krzemiński objects to the Western European image of Poland and implies that it has basically never changed since the partitions of Poland: “Like Kant once, so Habermas today”. Eastern Europe (in this case, Poland), according to his article, is still considered backward and deviating from Western European norms. Polish memory culture is contrasted with the historical consciousness of German middle-class citizens, who saw Poland first as an amorphous mass, the division of which was its own fault, then as a key place for the European fight for freedom, and finally as a beneficiary of the First World War. Yet Polish memory culture, as Krzemiński points out, makes the Polish commitment in the war on Iraq comprehensible. Indeed it is a symbolic deed with the...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.