Show Less
Restricted access

Contributions to Theory and Comparative History of Historiography

German and Brazilian Perspectives


Luiz Estevam de Oliveira Fernandes, Luísa Rauter Pereira and Sérgio da Mata

This book bears witness to the tightening of bonds that has been taking place among the Brazilian and the German historiographical communities in the last years. It presents a wide array of historiographical issues by various scholars: the role played by history writing in modern processes of nation-building, Alexander von Humboldt’s indirect Brazilian experience, the humanistic and methodical legacies of 19th century German historical thinking, current perspectives in the history of concepts, and the potentials and limits of history as a means for political education.
Show Summary Details
Restricted access

Facts and Fictions: Alexander von Humboldt in Brazil


During his nearly five-year journey in the Americas, Alexander von Humboldt visited parts of the Spanish colonial territories that would later become Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Mexico, and Cuba. He also briefly detoured to the USA. He never made it to Brazil—unless we believe Voltaire Schilling’s delightful fiction of Humboldt’s 1800 stray into Portuguese territory:

O sentinela estranhou-lhe a presença e os gestos. O que fazia aquele branco desconhecido, com a cara mordida pelos mosquitos, no meio da selva erguendo uma luneta para todos os lados? Naquela mesma noite, numa rápida operação, o naturalista alemão Alexander von Humboldt foi preso por uma patrulha portuguesa. Acusaram-no de espionagem. Transpusera sem querer os supostos limites que, em plena floresta amazônica, separavam o império espanhol do lusitano. Como poderia o pobre homem saber em meio ao colossal verdor qual árvore ou cipó, qual córrego ou igarapé, era o marco exato da fronteira?2 [The sentinel was taken aback by the presence of this man and his gesturing. What was that white stranger, his face bitten up by mosquitoes, doing in the jungle, pointing a telescope in all directions? That same night, in short order, the German naturalist Alexander von Humboldt was arrested by a Portuguese patrol. They accused him of spying. He had unwittingly crossed the supposed border that separated the Spanish from the Portuguese Empire in the dense Amazonian forest. How could the poor man know, amidst the gigantic verdure,...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.

Do you have any questions? Contact us.

Or login to access all content.