Essays and Appreciations in Honor of Michael J. Colacurcio’s 50 Years of Teaching
Edited By Carol M. Bensick
The Critic on Main Street: Hawthorne and Critical Allegory
In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s late short story “Main-street,” first published in 1849 and later included in The Snow-Image, and Other Twice-told Tales (1851), an itinerant showman presents a jerry-rigged version of a moving panorama, a “pictorial exhibition, somewhat in the nature of a puppet-show,” to a small-town audience.1 As the showman turns a crank, propelling wooden figures across a series of painted tableaux, the audience sees a forest clearing gradually transform from a primitive path lightly travelled by Native Americans and early settlers into a bustling town center, revealing along the way a parade of well-known New England historical figures and offering a condensed narrative of the progress of colonial American history. In producing the spectacle, however, the showman encounters a perhaps familiar problem: namely, there’s a heckler in the audience. The showman is only a few minutes into the performance when an audience member interrupts: “The whole affair is a manifest catch-penny,” the critic obtrudes: “The trees look more like weeds in a garden, than a primitive forest; the Squaw Sachem and Wappacowet are stiff in their pasteboard joints; and the squirrels, the deer, and the wolf, move with all the grace of a child’s wooden monkey, sliding up and down a stick” (XI: 52). The showman politely thanks the gentleman for the “candor of [his] remarks,” admits the rudimentary nature of the devices, and then calmly proceeds with the show—that is, until moments later, when the same man interrupts again, dismayed this...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.