New Perspectives from Legal and Political Theory
Edited By Antonia Geisler, Michael Hein and Siri Hummel
Separation of Powers reconsidered: a Proposal for a New Theoretical Model at the Beginning of the 21st Century
‘Separation of powers’ is a classic concept in political and legal theory. However, the key approaches that were elaborated at the beginning of modern constitutionalism are no longer appropriate for the reality of modern states. This chapter aims at introducing some alternative views with regard to the classification and delimitation of state powers. By means of a reassessment of the criteria for state powers differentiation, a seven-powers model is proposed, that comprises not only the classic trias politica of the legislative, executive and judicial branches, but also four new powers: external, financial, patronage and symbolic. Moreover, the difference between substantial, personal and symbolic policy-making is taken into account.
‘Separation of powers’ is a classic interdisciplinary topic of modern philosophy, constitutional theory and political science. Almost all social sciences work with or at least tackle some issues that belong to the concepts of powers’ separation and powers’ distribution, because these two intertwined – partially overlapping and partially dichotomic – concepts concern key problems of the social order, the constitutional order included. In particular, these problems are the prevention of power abuse, an optimum between distribution and concentration of power, the manageability of social and power diversity, and the establishment of a functional governmental structure. Furthermore, ‘Separation of powers’ is a brand name for complex institutional systems, a core element of democratic ideology and common heritage of the Western legal tradition and constitutional civilisation.
The idea of separation of powers is both rigid...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.