Show Less
Restricted access

The Best Surgeon in England

Percivall Pott, 1713–88


Lynda Payne

Percivall Pott (1713–88) was a leading surgeon in eighteenth-century Britain. This work mines the rich biographical and bibliographical record Pott and his students left behind to add to the historical and intellectual understanding of pre-modern surgery. This was a time when surgery was becoming professionalized. Pott maintained a significant role in crafting the image of a professional surgeon as someone who is capable of treating a multitude of poor hospital patients while at the same time effectively teaching operative skills and manners to the next generation of young men and running a successful and wealth-producing private practice.

Pott had more medical conditions named after him during his lifetime than any other surgeon of his era or since; analyzing what conditions surgeons claimed were theirs to manage and what ailments patients sought surgical solutions for reveals the importance and power of rhetoric in crafting the increasingly rigid definition of medicine as a sophisticated scientific activity rather than a mundane lay experience of treating sickness. The practice of naming conditions after surgeons also helps lay bare the power to classify and own certain sites in the body.

An account of Pott’s life and work challenges the prevailing view in historiographical works of surgery before the era of general anesthesia as a realm of screaming patients and larger than life eccentric medical men whose primary aims were to operate as fast as possible. Through an examination of the life and work of the man rated the best surgeon in England by his contemporaries, the whole field of surgery in history becomes humanized.

Show Summary Details
Restricted access



I would like to thank the many institutions and people that have provided financial and professional support over the years I have been researching and writing this monograph. My colleagues and students in the History Department at the University of Missouri–Kansas City (UMKC) have remained steadfast in their interest in Pott and his world. I was fortunate to receive the support of a Women and Gender Studies Research Grant at UMKC and a University of Missouri Research Board Grant to help fund this project. Susan Sykes-Berry, a reference librarian at UMKC’s Health Sciences Library, spent hundreds of hours collating primary research materials. At the University of Kansas Medical Center, Dawn McInnis at The Clendening History of Medicine Library provided invaluable help in locating surgical manuscripts and rare books. A Eugene W. J. Pearce, M. D. and Lunetta A. Pearce, M.D., Fellowship in the History of Medicine, Library and Archives at the University of Kansas enabled me to dig deeper into the wonderful collections of the Clendening Library. I also spent a summer in the Ebling Library for the Health Sciences funded by a Friends of the University of Wisconsin Libraries Research Grant-in-Aid. I wish to thank Mary E. Hitchcock and Micaela Sullivan-Fowler at the Ebling Library for their hard work in helping with my research.

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.

Do you have any questions? Contact us.

Or login to access all content.