The Social and Technical Anatomy of Digital Bodies
Edited By Jaime Banks
Chapter Twenty-Six: Mobility & Context: Of Being and Being There (Edward Downs)
| 257 →
Mobility & Context
Of Being and Being There
There is a long-standing debate in philosophical circles as to whether humans are products of their environments. While it is beyond the scope of this chapter to answer this question with certainty, it’s safe to say, in brief, that the answer is likely both yes and no. On one hand, a quote from author C. J. Heck famously illustrates the “yes” position, stating: “We are all products of our environment; every person we meet, every new experience or adventure, every book we read, touches and changes us, making us the unique being we are.” On the other hand, anthropologist Margaret Mead advocates for the “no” position, stating: “The notion that we are products of our environment is a sin; we are products of our choices.” Both have a point. If a person is born into an English-speaking family and learns to speak in English, it is reasonable to say the person is a product of the environment. Point for Heck. However, if they decide to study Farsi, Japanese, or Papiamentu, then their choice has dictated how they will engage the world through these languages. Point for Mead.
This may seem like a strange way to begin a chapter on avatars, but the tension between fate and free will—that is to say, emerging from environment or choice—is as real in the digital...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.