Show Less

«Poor Green Erin»

German Travel Writers’ Narratives on Ireland from Before the 1798 Rising to After the Great Famine- Texts Edited, Translated and Annotated by Eoin Bourke

Edited By Eoin Bourke

The area of 19 th -century German travel writing on Ireland has received widespread scholarly attention over the years in treatises in both English and German, but these efforts were directed largely at fellow-scholars and formed part of an academic discourse on travel, interculturality and alterity. This book, on the other hand, is conceived of more as a reader for the general public than as an academic treatise, presents a surprisingly extensive body of comments drawn from German and Austrian sources from between 1783 and 1865 and lets them «talk for themselves». Some of these remarkably empathetic and well-founded eye-witness accounts were translated into English already in the 19 th century by people like Sarah Austin and Sir Lascelles Wraxhall, but the editor has re-translated them to remove varying degrees of antiquatedness of formulation and has added other accounts that were hitherto largely unknown to the non-German-speaking reading public.
Show Summary Details
Restricted access

30 Leopold von Ranke (1865)

Extract

Leopold von Ranke (1795-1886), who stemmed from a solidly Protestant Saxon background, became one of Germany’s leading historians of the second half of the 19th century by establishing a new approach of basing historiography on verifiable data and gleaning “history as it was” from original documents. Al- though in his treatment of European issues he generally demonstrated “a sym- pathetic empathy with the Protestant cause”, in the case of Ireland he “showed open support for the Irish and their Catholic cause” [cf. Boldt 2007, 233f.]. This becomes evident in his comment in his History of England, vol. III on Oliver Cromwell’s vengeful siege of Drogheda in 1649: Did Cromwell really imagine that he was executing the justice of God on these people, whose hands were allegedly stained with innocent blood? Can he possibly have believed, as he claimed, that he was driven by a higher divine spirit? [LvR 1861, 346f.] And in his diaries he drew a comparison between the Cromwellian invasion and the brutal English suppression of the Great Indian mutiny of 1858 with the remark: “Almost as Cromwell treated the Irish. But is this fair? Is this not ex- cessive violence?” [cit. Boldt 2007, 163] His interest in Ireland was certainly intensified by marrying Clarissa Graves, who had grown up in the lap of a distinguished Anglo-Irish Protestant family in 13 Merrion Square and 12 Fitzwilliam Square. She travelled widely throughout Europe in her mother’s company and was first introduced to Ranke in Paris in the summer of...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.

Do you have any questions? Contact us.

Or login to access all content.