Show Less


The Preludes and Beyond

Bengt Edlund

The first study of this volume looks for reminiscences of Dies Irae in Chopin’s works. A great number of allusions and affinities are found in the preludes as well as in Chopin’s output. The study also yields insights into Chopin’s composition method. These intertextual findings are used in an attempt to establish the extra-musical content of the Second Ballade. Five preludes – A minor, E minor, B minor, A major and C minor – are closely examined, using diverse analytical approaches. A primary concern is to critically assess previous readings, and Schenkerian ones in particular. An analysis of the initial right-hand passage of the F-minor étude from Méthode brings up matters of idiomatic and ontology.


Show Summary Details
Restricted access

Chapter 7. The phenomenology of fingering Structure and ontology in the F-minor Etude from Méthode des méthodes


Chapter 7 The phenomenology of fingering Structure and ontology in the F-minor Etude from Méthode des méthodes Although much will be said here about Chopin’s F-minor Etude from Méthode des Méthodes - or actually about its first 24 notes - the points to be made transcend this specific object of study. The present essay deals with certain aspects of interpretation (taken to be what you understand when seeing, hearing, and/or performing a piece of music) and with how the phenomenal structure of music necessarily affects its ontological status.1 The main purpose is to actualize matters that are frequently neglected, although analysts, aestheticians, and musicians ought to keep them in mind. The initial passage from Chopin’s etude merely serves as an example, which could be exchanged for others, but one can hardly think of a more economical and inspiring material than this introductory right-hand melody, full of structural smartness and manual delights. I will begin by giving a critical background to the main issues. The bulk of the essay will be devoted to a thorough analysis of the passage, starting with some structural observations that may occur to a musically imaginative reader, turning then to a description of the melody as a heard phenomenon, and ending with a presentation of meanings that emerge only to the pianist, partly as a result of the fingering chosen. In the last sections, I will return to the broader problems, offering a further discussion and some conclusions. 1 An earlier version...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.

Do you have any questions? Contact us.

Or login to access all content.