Some of the Major Issues in Philosophy
Part I: KNOWLEDGE. A REVIEW OF THE ISSUE OF SCEPTICISM
Part I KNOWLEDGE. A REVIEW OF THE ISSUE OF SCEPTICISM 1. The importance of the questions of scepticism and dogmatism in the history of philosophy Scepticism has accompanied philosophy almost from the very start. At times the matter has been brought to a head, such as Plato’s dispute with the Sophists, as well as, in a curious way, the famous medieval dispute of the “dialectists” (i.e. philosophers) with the “antidialectists” (i.e. enemies of philosophers). Yet only in modern philosophy, in the search for metaphysical truth in the self-knowledge of understanding, has the problem become a fundamental one for philosophy – which does not mean that it has been treated in an impartial fashion, in accordance with the demands we place on the rationality of the philosopher. All too often, analysis has been replaced by tirades. Indeed, practically the whole of modern philosophy, up until the mid-20th century, was consumed by a fear of scepticism and dogmatism. How, then, to sail between the Scylla of scepticism and the Charybdis of dogmatism? This was a question that tormented Descartes, Kant, Husserl and many others besides. The answer that usually emerged was thus: trust what in your reason is its essential and own form of organisation, its a priori essence, and in this trust allow yourself to be led through the clear, unbiased experiencing of the thing itself, i.e. that which is clearly presented and cannot be different from how it is. The necessity emerging from apparently accidental experiences charmed us and made us...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.