Show Less

Mapping Academic Values in the Disciplines

A Corpus-Based Approach


Davide Simone Giannoni

A broad strand of applied linguistic research has focused on the language of science and scholarship, stressing its role in the construction and negotiation of knowledge claims. Central to the success of such texts is the use of evaluative expressions encoding what is considered to be desirable or undesirable in a given domain. While the speech acts relevant to evaluation have been extensively researched, little is known of the underlying values they encode. This volume seeks to fill the gap by exploring the main facets of academic value in a corpus of research articles from leading journals in anthropology, biology, computer science, economics, engineering, history, mathematics, medicine, physics and sociology. The collocations and qualified entities associated with such variables in the corpus provide insights into how scholars draw on a repertoire of conventional, largely unqualified, axiological meanings instrumental to the production of new knowledge in their field.


Show Summary Details
Restricted access

2. Theoretical background 19


19 2. Theoretical background 2.1. Academia and the disciplines Academic institutions are entrusted with the production and dis- semination of knowledge in virtually every field of study amenable to systematic investigation. Many of the intellectual revolutions that have shaped Western civilization, from humanism to the Protestant reformation, from Cartesian science to rationalism, were a result of academic debates spilling over into society, often beyond the original intention of their proponents. The century-old history of academia reaches back to the late Middle Ages, when the Universitas magistrorum (literally, ‘corporation of teachers’) gained control of educational functions previously reserved to monks and clerics. For this reason, universities are among the oldest surviving European institutions, with Bologna, Cambridge, Coimbra, Naples, Oxford, Padua, Paris and Siena established as early as the 12th-13th centuries (cf. Feingold 2000). But age alone is not a fair predictor of future success: in a recent list of world universities ranked chiefly by peer- review score, scholarly impact and student/faculty ratio, only four European universities – all British – appeared among the top twenty institutions (THES 2007). Since the 1870s, European universities have been deeply influenced by the German model advocated by Wilhelm von Humboldt (cf. Anderson 2004), which pursues an integration of educational and research activities to serve the converging interests of faculty and students. However, a recent assessment (Pritchard 2004) of Humboldtian values in German universities exposes the distance between reality and the ideal: unsolved issues in the faculty-student relationship are today complicated by the ‘corporate university’ model, driven by...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.

Do you have any questions? Contact us.

Or login to access all content.