Edited By Piotr Stalmaszczyk and Luis Fernández Moreno
Manuel García-Carpintero - Predicativism and the Mill-Frege Theory of Proper Names
| 21 →
University of Barcelona
Predicativism and the Mill-Frege Theory of Proper Names*
1. Metalinguistic descriptivism and its varieties
In this paper I compare an account of the semantics of proper names that I have been defending in the past with related predicativist views that have recently become prominent, and argue in favor of the former. I call the account the Mill-Frege theory because of its syncretic features: it combines important tenets of Fregean views with central features of the theory of direct reference. According to the Mill-Frege theory, proper names are (in a sense) mere tags that lack connotation, and are therefore rigid designators; this explains the ‘Mill’, while the ‘Frege’ is explained by the fact that the account makes this claim compatible with core tenets of Fregean theories of reference. According to the account, proper names have linguistic senses, known by competent speakers on the basis of their linguistic competence. The Mill-Frege theory thus rejects strict Millianism, as defined here:
According to Mill, a proper name is, so to speak, simply a name. It simply refers to its bearer, and has no other linguistic function. In particular, unlike a definite description, a name does not describe its bearer as possessing any special identifying properties. (Kripke 1979: 239–240)
The Mill-Frege account is a version of the sort of metalinguistic descriptivism that Kripke (1980: 68–74) criticizes as circular. It shares this important...
You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.
This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.
Do you have any questions? Contact us.Or login to access all content.