Show Less
Restricted access

Evidence, Experiment and Argument in Linguistics and the Philosophy of Language

Series:

Edited By Martin Hinton

This volume is concerned with issues in experimental philosophy and experimental linguistics. Examining experiments in language from a variety of perspectives, it asks what form they should take and what should count as evidence. There is particular focus on the status of linguistic intuitions and the use of language corpora. A number of papers address issues of methodology in experimental work, while other contributions examine the use of thought experiments and what the hypothetical can tell us about the actual. The aim of this collection is to bring together the work of linguists and philosophers in order that they may learn from one another, and to help both groups understand how the use of experimental methods can affect the arguments they employ and the claims they make.
Show Summary Details
Restricted access

Geoffrey Sampson - Two Ideas of Creativity

Extract

| 15 →

Geoffrey Sampson

University of Sussex

Two ideas of creativity

Discussion of the scientific status of linguistics is often clouded by an ambiguity in the terms “creative”, “creativity”. Linguists have taken to using these words in a way that is very different from the way they are used in everyday English, and this idiosyncratic usage is arguably responsible for serious misunderstandings about the nature of human language.

Whether or not they regard the influence of Chomsky’s linguistic writings as positive, many people agree in seeing those writings, from the 1957 book Syntactic Structures onward, as having brought about a “revolution” in the discourse of linguistics. One leading feature of that “revolution” is said to be that Chomsky drew attention to the fact that language behaviour is creative. What is meant, by those who say this, is that the grammar rules of a human language allow an infinitely numerous range of distinct grammatical sentences, so that most sentences we utter or hear have never been uttered or heard by us (and perhaps by anyone) before. Human languages are contrasted in this respect with the signalling systems used by some animal species, which are said to comprise small finite ranges of possible signals.

Thus, Sir John Lyons’s Chomsky (1970) was a concise summary of Chomsky’s linguistics, addressed to the educated general reader, by an author with wide intellectual horizons who was broadly sympathetic to his subject without being an uncritical...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.

Do you have any questions? Contact us.

Or login to access all content.