Show Less
Restricted access

Legal Professions at the Crossroads

Series:

Edited By Dariusz Jemielniak

The book collects research-driven chapters from different disciplines: anthropology, sociology, management, and law. It addresses the issues of legal and administrative professionals’ identity, ethics, and workplace enactment. Through an analysis of different groups of lawyers and paralegals, conducted by quantitative or qualitative methods, it draws conclusions on the general condition of these occupations and their role in the society. In particular, the volume covers the issues of criminal judges’ roles, the interplay of law and politics in judicial decisions, and the ways they are standardized. It also addresses the topics of professional logic in public administration, as well as charisma and identity work among lawyers, including LLM students from top world programs. Through an analysis of qualitative interviews, it describes the legal workplace, especially in terms of time commitments. It also disputes the problems of professional ethics in everyday legal work.
Show Summary Details
Restricted access

Standardization of Judicial Opinions: Work of Judges in a Changing Environment

Extract

Tomasz Raburski, Maciej Wojciechowski

Judges are the most significant knowledge workers within the legal field. They occupy the central position in the legal system, and their work is crucial for modern democracies and the capitalist system (Epstein, 2005).

The role and position of judges in modern society go through major transformation. Their importance increasesas the most heated debates move from the parliaments to the courts. This shift has led some researchers to call modern democracies „juristocracies“ - regimes in which courts play the dominant role (Goldstein, 2004). The recent advance of technology is another factor that deeply transforms the legal field (Tiersma, 2010). In many countries the transition from manual and typewriter bureaucracies to computer bureaucracies is still at the initial stage (Waseda University International e-Government Ranking 2013, 2013). Among variety of crises discernible in the contemporary world legal field is particularly affected by a crisis of legitimacy(Habermas, 1980). It concerns many institutions whose reason of being (raison d’etre) has never been questioned before. Infallibility of judges‘ is now commonly considered a myth, and their role as „only the mouth that pronounces the words of law“ (Montesquieu), seems no longer an adequate view of their professional activity, regardless of common law or civil law system. Judges are regarded neither as the only legal experts nor „high priests of law“ whose decisions are correct just because they have been rendered by them (Łętowska, 1997).

The body of literature on the work of judges is...

You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article.

This site requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books or journals.

Do you have any questions? Contact us.

Or login to access all content.