Stages of Change
British Women Playwrights from the 1980s to the 2000s
Summary
Petra Kalavská’s book on contemporary British female dramatists is not only highly readable, but extremely informative and erudite. Stages of Change: British Women Playwrights from the 1980s to the 2000s will be of great interest for academics, students of theatre and literature and the general public. The monograph documents how feminist theatre has been alive and well and very much vibrant in Great Britain up to the early 2000s.’ – David Livingstone, Palacký University Olomouc
Excerpt
Table Of Contents
- Cover
- Title Page
- Copyright Page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- Chapter 1 Liberal Feminism: From Theory to Playwriting and Theatrical Practice
- 1.1 Anglo-American Feminist Theory: Liberal Feminism
- 1.2 Liberal Feminist Theatre and Methods of Dramatic Writing
- Chapter 2 Out of the Prisonhouse: British Radical Feminist Theatre and Sarah Daniels’s Ripen Our Darkness and Masterpieces
- 2.1 Anglo-American Feminist Theory: Radical and Cultural Feminism
- 2.2 Radical Feminist Theatre
- 2.3 Radical Feminist Methods of Dramatic Writing
- 2.4 Sarah Daniels: Ripen Our Darkness
- 2.5 Sarah Daniels: Masterpieces
- Chapter 3 Brechtian Theory Revisited: British Socialist Feminist Theatre and Caryl Churchill’s Top Girls and Fen
- 3.1 Anglo-American Feminist Theory: Socialist Feminism
- 3.2 Socialist Feminist Theatre
- 3.3 Socialist Feminist Methods of Dramatic Writing
- 3.4 Caryl Churchill: Top Girls
- 3.5 Caryl Churchill: Fen
- Chapter 4 Women’s Voices at the Century’s End: The Postfeminist Landscape
- 4.1 Postfeminism, ʻGirl Powerʼ and All That
- 4.2 New Writing in the Postfeminist Era
- 4.3 New Writing and Its Methods
- 4.4 Judy Upton: Ashes and Sand
- 4.5 Judy Upton: Sunspots
- 4.6 Rebecca Prichard: Essex Girls
- 4.7 Rebecca Prichard: Yard Gal
- Chapter 5 New Writing at the Turn of the Millennium: debbie tucker green
- 5.1 Form and Resistance in debbie tucker green’s Early Work
- 5.2 debbie tucker green: dirty butterfly
- Conclusion
- Bibliography
- Index
Acknowledgements
The completion of this monograph was made possible through the financial support of the Faculty of Arts and Philosophy of the University of Pardubice, to which I am affiliated. I am also grateful to my colleagues Šárka Bubíková and Olga Roebuck from the Department of English and American Studies for their encouragement and generous support. Without this financial and collegial assistance, I would not have been able to complete this book.
Earlier versions of parts of this monograph appeared in the articles ‘The Reversal of Gender Roles: Girl Gangs in Rebecca Prichard’s Yard Gal’, Ostrava Journal of English Philology, 15/2 (2023): 19–30 and ‘Out of the Prisonhouse: British Radical Feminist Theatre and Sarah Daniels’ Ripen Our Darkness and Masterpieces’, Brno Studies in English, 51/1 (2025): 169–187.
Introduction
The 1980s were a decade of significant creative activity by women dramatists in British theatre. In reference to the period, a number of theatre critics lamented the absence of new drama, while many theoreticians emphasised the emerging importance of women playwrights. Many British women dramatists were concerned with feminism, at least in some of their plays. Being a woman playwright often meant going through a feminist stage in an attempt to break up the male discourse by means of form, style and new themes. Feminism was a transgressive force widely used on the British stage during the 1980s although, by the mid-decade, antifeminist sentiment had already begun to emerge in British society.
While in the 1980s the surge of women’s creative activity was undeniable, in the 1990s few new women dramatists emerged. Aleks Sierz refers to a new generation of playwrights, born around 1970 and raised in the 1980s, as ‘Thatcher’s Children’,1 and Elaine Aston characterises them as consisting ‘mostly [of] angry young men, joined by a few angry young women’.2 At first glance, plays by the younger generation of women seem deeply imbued with what Aston calls ‘the feminism fatigue of a 1990s postfeminist society’.3 Written in a postfeminist context, when equality between the sexes and women’s full access to independence were presented as already achieved and when feminism was increasingly regarded as rigid and passé, these plays differ significantly from the work by the older generation staged in the 1980s.
In The Cambridge Companion to Modern British Women Playwrights, editors Elaine Aston and Janelle Reinelt explain why the dramatists Sarah Kane and Rebecca Prichard (Judy Upton is not mentioned in the volume) are not included in the study: ‘[b]oth Prichardʼs and Kaneʼs theatrical landscapes are “frightening” [Aston and Reinelt refer to the prediction of the ‘frightening’ future for impoverished women which closes Caryl Churchill’s Top Girls], but in very different ways which it would be wrong to try and make “fit” into some category of “women’s playwriting”’.4 Although the work by the younger generation of women was not perceived as fitting into the category of women’s drama, the present monograph is informed by more recent research which suggests that these plays can be disinterred from what Aston calls ‘a masculine cult of “in-yer-face-ism”’5 and studied in the context of women’s playwriting.
This book provides a cross-generational analysis of women’s drama from the 1980s to the early 2000s and explores a shift in the (feminist) discourse as reflected in works by British women playwrights. It connects the explicitly feminist theatre of the 1980s – with its new forms, styles and distinctive themes – to the more subdued modes of feminist expression that emerged in the 1990s. New writing at the turn of the twenty-first century is examined through attention to debbie tucker green, who synthesises a range of influences in her early work. Without such a cross-generational perspective, the relationship between the explicitly feminist theatre of the 1980s and later developments in women’s drama remains obscured. This book offers a historically grounded study of women’s playwriting and traces how feminist discussion transformed rather than disappeared while examining how this transformation is articulated through theatrical form, style, thematic concerns and their performance.
The plays written in the 1980s by British women playwrights are often informed by Anglo-American feminist theory, which is heterogeneous and not theoretically unified and is often divided into bourgeois/liberal, radical/cultural and socialist/materialist feminism. Although the three gradually evolving yet different political approaches became increasingly blurred and their boundaries indistinct, ‘the three dominant strands of feminist enquiry’, as Aston explains, ‘have been adopted and developed in methods and techniques of dramatic writing, and performance aesthetics’.6 The fact that this feminist approach is far from old-fashioned is demonstrated in Restaging Feminisms (2020), in which Aston explores contemporary British theatre through the lens of three feminist strands (liberal, radical and socialist).7 The tripartite model of liberal, radical and socialist feminism is used here as a structuring framework which not only provides a theoretical background but also connects feminist theory with dramatic form and performance aesthetics and enables a focus on the nuances of the analysed plays. Moreover, it serves as a means of organising a large and diverse body of plays written in the 1980s and establishes a basis for a cross-generational discussion.
This book suggests that radical and socialist feminist drama responds to Hélène Cixousʼs call for writing specifically by and for women, that is, that women should ‘[w]rite [and] let no one hold [them] back’.8 As the feminist debate in the plays written in the 1980s is often supported by formal aspects, this monograph examines how women playwrights challenge realism through experimentation which enables them to develop their own aesthetic strategies. It also engages with more recent reconsiderations of realism and suggests that the plays which do not systematically challenge realist conventions nonetheless have their place in the British dramatic landscape. The discussion of the rigorous re-examination of realist structures by radical and socialist feminist playwrights establishes a cross-generational bridge as the younger generation of women playwrights studied in the chapter on new writing in the 1990s does not emphasise the innovative elements that were central to earlier feminist playwriting. While the feminist critique of realism has been rethought, it remains analytically useful as a historically grounded framework that enables the examination of the relationship between theatrical form and feminist politics.
The book studies in detail nine plays which achieved mainstream success and were first performed in British theatres that at the time promoted new work. Apart from Sunspots (first produced at the Red Room) and dirty butterfly (first staged at the Soho Theatre), all the plays either premiered at the Royal Court Theatre or transferred there the same year (Fen and Masterpieces). Four of the plays chosen for analysis were written at the beginning of the 1980s by dramatists who were influenced by feminist discourses and who emerged as leading feminist playwrights in Britain. While Caryl Churchillʼs (1938) Top Girls (1982) and Fen (1983) can be labelled as socialist feminist plays, Sarah Danielsʼs (1957) Ripen Our Darkness (1981) and Masterpieces (1983) examine and promote radical feminist politics. It is no coincidence that the analytical chapters concentrate on the work by two dramatists, each of whom is engaged with a different strand of feminism. Four other plays were written in the 1990s by a younger generation of playwrights, women representatives of in-yer-face theatre: Ashes and Sand (1994) and Sunspots (1996) by Judy Upton (1967) and Essex Girls (1994) and Yard Gal (1998) by Rebecca Prichard (1971). The in-yer-face legacy, subtle feminism and political themes conveyed implicitly are also apparent in debbie tucker green’s dirty butterfly (2003) in which marginalised identities are foregrounded through the intersection of gender, class and race.
Although the present monograph closely analyses nine plays by five British women playwrights, it also provides a wider context by considering other (women) dramatists and their work. Apart from the playwrights mentioned above, it devotes particular attention to Kay Adshead, Cordelia Ditton and Maggie Ford, Andrea Dunbar, Nell Dunn, Tasha Fairbanks, Pam Gems, Debbie Horsfield, Sarah Kane, Jackie Kay, Charlotte Keatley, Bryony Lavery, Deborah Levy, Claire Luckham, Clare McIntyre, Louise Page, Winsome Pinnock and Jacqueline Rudet while referring to male dramatists where relevant. The book does not attempt, however, to provide an exhaustive list of female playwrights, as it limits its scope to 1980s dramatists whose work fits one of the three dominant strands of feminist enquiry (liberal, radical and socialist), and does not examine Northern Irish, Scottish or Welsh dramatists. The chapter on the 1990s considers only new writing and in-yer-face theatre and the chapter on new writing at the turn of the millennium explores early work by debbie tucker green. While this monograph does not primarily concentrate on (feminist) theatre companies, it acknowledges the importance of Clean Break, Gay Sweatshop, Joint Stock, Monstrous Regiment, Red Ladder, Siren Theatre Company, the Black Theatre Co-operative, The Red Room, the Theatre of Black Women, The Women’s Playhouse Trust and The Women’s Theatre Group/The Sphinx – companies with which the playwrights discussed cooperated.
The first chapter studies liberal feminist theory, theatre and methods of dramatic writing. It focuses on liberal feminism, which has its roots in the more than three-hundred-year-old history of liberal philosophy. Before concentrating on modern liberal feminist thought, the chapter briefly outlines liberal philosophy and explains how it influenced early liberal feminism. The second part of the chapter considers liberal feminist drama. Although many of these plays were initially received unfavourably by feminist critics because of their contents, contexts and forms, I attempt to rehabilitate their importance, suggesting that they have a place within the feminist theatrical landscape of the 1980s.
While radical feminism and cultural feminism are sometimes perceived as synonymous expressions related merely to different cultural and geographical backgrounds, respectively to British and American contexts, the first part of the second chapter differentiates between radical and cultural feminism, suggesting that each refers to clearly distinct conceptions of women. The chapter then explores radical feminist theatre in Britain and demonstrates how radical feminist debate in the plays is often supported by formal aspects. It focuses on radical feminist playwriting and addresses the question of form which, as radical feminists believe, reflects sexual difference between men and women. The analyses of Sarah Daniels’s Ripen Our Darkness and Masterpieces suggest that Daniels systematically breaks realism and supports radical feminist discussion through formal experimentation.
Despite being associated with the second half of the twentieth century, socialist feminism cannot be said to build on an ahistorical framework, as is the case for radical feminism. The third chapter explores in more depth the importance of socialist feminist thought and briefly maps the Marxist approach to women and feminism. Socialist feminism is inspired by Marxist theory, which it utilises but also re-examines and re-contextualises. The chapter suggests that the insufficiency of the Marxist approach leads socialist feminists to explore gender conditioning and draw on Sigmund Freud’s theories in order to understand patriarchal structures, categorise women’s subordinate position in society and examine psychological masculinity and femininity. The chapter explores socialist feminist theatre in Britain and points out that the content of socialist feminist plays is often maintained and supported by Brechtian techniques. After providing a broader context, the chapter outlines Bertolt Brecht’s theories and argues, through analyses, that the explicitly political debate in Caryl Churchill’s Top Girls and Fen is supported by formal experimentation. An emphasis is placed on how Churchill reworks Brechtian techniques to develop her own strategies of fragmentation and re-examination of realist structures.
Details
- Pages
- X, 138
- Publication Year
- 2027
- ISBN (PDF)
- 9781803749006
- ISBN (ePUB)
- 9781803749013
- ISBN (Hardcover)
- 9781803748993
- DOI
- 10.3726/b22619
- Language
- English
- Publication date
- 2026 (November)
- Keywords
- "Ashes and Sand" British Women Playwrights Caryl Churchill debbie tucker green "dirty butterfly" "Essex Girls" "Fen" In-Yer-Face Theatre Judy Upton "Masterpieces" Rebecca Prichard "Ripen Our Darkness" Sarah Daniels "Sunspots" "Top Girls" "Yard Gal"
- Published
- Oxford, Berlin, Bruxelles, Chennai, Lausanne, New York, 2027. x, 138 pp.
- Product Safety
- Peter Lang Group AG