Loading...

Phronetic Science

Morally Guided and Praxis-oriented Science Education

by Rouhollah Aghasaleh (Volume editor) Sara Tolbert (Volume editor) Kathryn Scantlebury (Volume editor) Bhaskar Upadhyay (Volume editor)
©2026 Textbook X, 176 Pages
Series: Bios-Mythois, Volume 3

Summary

The 21st century has exposed the limitations of Modernist dualist logic in addressing the complexities of contemporary life. Entities like COVID-19 and the environmental crisis exemplify "dualism-busting assemblages of the Capitalocene," presenting humanity with wicked problems that defy traditional ontologies. In this context, phronetic science—rooted in practical wisdom and morally guided praxis—offers an alternative approach to navigating equivocal circumstances for the common good. Western Modern Science has long dominated curriculum, teaching, and research, yet emergent science education scholars must now grapple with issues of equity, identity, and justice. This requires engaging with critical, feminist, Indigenous, decolonial, post-humanist, and other transformative perspectives. These alternative epistemologies and ontologies challenge hegemonic paradigms, urging new ways of conceptualizing research in science teaching and learning that are more inclusive, ethical, and responsive to the diverse realities of our interconnected world.

Table Of Contents

  • Cover
  • Title Page
  • Copyright Page
  • Contents
  • List of Figures
  • List of Tables
  • Foreword (Ajay Sharma)
  • References
  • Introduction (Rouhollah Aghasaleh, Sara Tolbert, Kathryn Scantlebury, and Bhaskar Upadhyay)
  • Femtoring as Praxis
  • Feminisms
  • Racial Justice
  • Art and Spirituality
  • References
  • Part I Feminist Wonderings
  • Introduction (Rouhollah Aghasaleh)
  • Envisioning Care in Secondary Science Classrooms: A Poststructural Feminist Provocation (Caroline Spurgin)
  • Introduction
  • Conceptual Framework
  • Methods
  • Context, Participants, and Data Collection
  • Data Analysis
  • Findings
  • Ernie
  • Stella
  • Discussion/Implications
  • References
  • Ecofeminism and the Nature of Science (Suzanne Poole Patzelt)
  • Introduction
  • Why Ecofeminism?
  • Theoretical Framework
  • Ecofeminism
  • Ecofeminism in the Science Education Literature
  • Contemporary Construction of the NOS
  • Toward an Ecofeminist Portrayal of the Nature of Science
  • Whose Creativity?
  • Who Is Considered?
  • Which Collaborators?
  • An Ecofeminist Characterization of the Nature of Science
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • Spacetimematter Entanglements in Digital Environmental Stories (Mary E. Short)
  • Introduction
  • Thinking with Theory
  • Spacetimemattering
  • Apparatuses
  • Video One: Trash in Parks
  • Agentic Realism in Trash in Parks
  • Video Two: Plastic and Trash Affecting Animals
  • Agential Realism in Plastic and Trash Affecting Animals
  • The Becomingness of Digital Media
  • References
  • Feminist Wonderings (Kathryn Scantlebury)
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • Part II Justice
  • Introduction (Bhaskar Upadhyay)
  • Unpacking the Eu[ro]thanization of Blackness in STEM Education (Takeshia Pierre, Theila Smith, and Bhaskar Upadhyay)
  • Situating the History of Racism in STEM Education
  • Positioning of Blackness in STEM: Inclusion of Critical Race Theory and Culturally Affirming Pedagogies
  • A brief Pause to Examine the Concept of Resilience
  • Call for Justice-oriented Science Education that Centers Blackness
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • Science Instructors’ New Approaches to Teaching During COVID-19 Pandemic (Olena James)
  • Introduction
  • Teaching Science Online During the Pandemic
  • Students’ Experiences
  • Research Question
  • Theoretical Framework
  • Data Organization
  • Data Analysis
  • Participant Descriptions
  • Reflecting on Pandemic Impact
  • Reflecting on New Teaching Practices
  • Discussion
  • References
  • Euro-Thanatology and Resurrecting Pluriversality in Science Education (Jennifer Adams)
  • Black Death in STEM
  • The Euro-Thanasic System
  • Shifting Pedagogies
  • References
  • Part III Artistic and Spiritual Dimensions of Science
  • Introduction (Sara Tolbert)
  • Integrating Art and Storytelling for Volcano Science Education: Teaching Multiple Skills Across Age Groups (Sriparna Saha and Ben Kennedy)
  • Introduction: Storytelling and Its Implications for Volcano Science Communication
  • Incorporating Art into Curriculum Design and Its Implications for Volcano Crisis Communication
  • Methods
  • The Curricular Resource: The Kid Who Cried Supervolcano
  • Participants & Demography
  • Curricular Reception: What Are the Artifacts Telling Us?
  • Case 1: Intermediate School Settings
  • Case 2: Teacher Training Settings
  • Undergraduate Classroom
  • Discussion
  • Multi-modality of a Resource Can Support the Development of Multiple Skills Across Different Age Groups
  • Considerations for Resource Adaptability
  • Summary
  • Acknowledgments
  • References
  • Supplementary Information
  • Kid Who Cried Supervolcano: Summary of the Activity
  • Learning Goal(s)
  • Instructions for School Students (5–13 Years)
  • Instructions for Teacher Training Workshops
  • What Could Be an Artistic Expression of Your Local Caldera Volcano?
  • After Reading the Story, Reflect on These Questions
  • Research Your Local Caldera Volcano
  • Rethink the Volcano Illustration
  • Love and Spirituality in Evolution Education (Joshua S. Hoskinson)
  • Introduction
  • Love as an Emancipatory Framework
  • Spirituality as Humanization
  • Love and Spirituality in Evolution Education
  • Macroevolution and Evolution Acceptance
  • Culturally Competent Evolution Education
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • Into the Rhizome: STEMtelling, as a Pedagogical Storytelling Method in Science Education (Jenny Tilsen)
  • Storytelling in Science Education
  • Into the Rhizome
  • Background and Motivation
  • Place and People
  • Rhizomatic STEMtelling
  • The Principle of Cartography and Decalcomania
  • The Principles of Connection and Heterogeneity
  • The Principle of Multiplicity
  • The Principle of Rupture
  • Conclusion: Processes and Structures of STEMtelling
  • References
  • Centering Learners’ Meaning-Making in Counter-Hegemonic Science Education (Alexandra Schindel)
  • Pedagogies of Love and Care
  • Counter-Hegemonic Science Curricula
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • Conclusion: From Knowledge and Practice to Wisdom (Sara Tolbert, Rouhollah Aghasaleh, Kathryn Scantlebury, and Bhaskar Upadhyay)

Figures

Spacetimematter Entanglements in Digital Environmental Stories

Mary E. Short

Figure 1: Colton in the park

Figure 2: Colton illustrates cause and consequences of plastic bags

Figure 3: Scientists from the Environmental Center of the University of Bergen reveal the contents of a whale’ stomach contain plastic

Figure 4: Using objects to reimagine

Integrating Art and Storytelling for Volcano Science Education: Teaching Multiple Skills Across Age Groups

Sriparna Saha and Ben Kennedy

Figure 1: Artifacts generated by the intermediate school students

Figure 2: Clockwise direction: Poster sequence with annotations that highlight the dynamic nature of Lake Taupō and how it can support various activities for people

Figure 3: Collaborative posters highlighting different aspects of the local volcano chosen by the different groups. Some groups (Figure 3a and 3c) respond to the prompt, “What is the personality of your local volcano?” The posters are annotated and communicate information about the frequency of eruptions

Figure 4: An undergraduate student generated artifact depicting a cautionary tale around a limnic eruption hazard

Figure 5: Artwork showcasing volcanic hazards around lahar flows in the context of Mt. Ruapehu which is an active volcano in NZ

Figure 6: Student artifact showcasing the coloring book that communicates the sequence of events that preceded the 1980 St. Helens eruption

Into the Rhizome: STEMtelling, as a Pedagogical Storytelling Method in Science Education

Jenny Tilsen

Figure 1: Principles of rhizome theory (Deleuze & Guattari, 1987)

Figure 2: The principles of connection and heterogeneity in STEMtelling

Figure 3: Principle of multiplicity in STEMtelling

Figure 4: Principle of rupture in STEMtelling

Tables

Ecofeminism and the Nature of Science

Suzanne Poole Patzelt

Table 1: The Eight Features of the Nature of Science (NGSS Appendix H, 2012)

Table 2: Conceptions of the nature of science[[/i]] (Abd-El-Khalick, 2012)

Table 3: An Ecofeminist Characterization of the Nature of Science

Science Instructors’ New Approaches to Teaching During COVID-19 Pandemic

Olena James

Table 1: Interview Discussion Topic and Corresponding Interview Question

Table 2: Demographic Variables for Selected 9 Biology Instructors

Integrating Art and Storytelling for Volcano Science Education: Teaching Multiple Skills Across Age Groups

Sriparna Saha and Ben Kennedy

Table 1: A summary of the target audience, activity prompt and objectives that underpinned the use of the resource, “The Kid Who Cried Supervolcano” in various settings

Table 2A: Summary of various skills, curricular goals and activity elements for “The Kid Who Cried Supervolcano” used across the school students and teacher training group

Table 2B: Summary of learning goals, skills and settings that “The Kid Who Cried Supervolcano” was used in the undergraduate geology classroom

Into the Rhizome: STEMtelling, as a Pedagogical Storytelling Method in Science Education

Jenny Tilsen

Table 1: Seth’s written STEMtell

Foreword

Ajay Sharma

Reading newspapers, nothing feels stable about this world. Things we took for granted, such as the peaceful transition of power in established democracies, appear increasingly precarious. While ideas that not so long ago could only make sense in dystopian fiction, such as deadly worldwide pandemics and people dying of heat strokes in rich societies, are becoming increasingly commonplace. The relentless barrage of crisis stories overwhelms us into a state of numbness, making crises seem ordinary and wearing us down as we try to go about our lives. This feeling of crisis ordinariness (Berlant, 2020) makes one wonder if we are on the brink of significant epochal changes. Indeed, some scholars, such as Fraser (2019) have characterized our historical present as a Gramscian interregnum characterized by the morbid fact that “the old is dying and the new cannot be born” (Gramsci, 1971).

Details

Pages
X, 176
Publication Year
2026
ISBN (PDF)
9781636670560
ISBN (ePUB)
9781636670577
ISBN (Softcover)
9781636670591
ISBN (Hardcover)
9781636670584
DOI
10.3726/b23920
Language
English
Publication date
2026 (October)
Keywords
phronetic science poststructuralism ethics science education critical pedagogy equity social justice feminist theory Indigenous knowledge decolonial studies post-humanism ontology epistemology new materialism praxis sustainability Capitalocene Anthropocene
Published
New York, Berlin, Bruxelles, Chennai, Lausanne, Oxford, 2026. X, 176 pp., 9 b/w ill., 5 color ill., 9 tables.
Product Safety
Peter Lang Group AG

Biographical notes

Rouhollah Aghasaleh (Volume editor) Sara Tolbert (Volume editor) Kathryn Scantlebury (Volume editor) Bhaskar Upadhyay (Volume editor)

Rouhollah Aghasaleh, PhD, is an associate professor in the School of Education at California State Polytechnic University, Humboldt. Sara Tolbert is Professor of Science and Environmental Education at Monash University, where she co-directs the Science Education in the Anthropocene Impact Lab (SEALab) and leads the Science Education Research Group (SERG). She holds an honorary professorship at the University of Canterbury in Aotearoa New Zealand. Kathryn Scantlebury is Professor Emerita from the University of Delaware, a guest researcher at the Centre for Gender Research at Uppsala University, Sweden, and an Honorary Professorial Fellow at the University of Melbourne, Australia. Bhaskar Upadhyay is Rodney Wallace Professor for the Advancement of Teaching and Learning in the College of Education and Human Development, University of Minnesota.

Previous

Title: Phronetic Science