Judges, Independence and the Rule of Law in Germany
The EU Perspective
Summary
Excerpt
Table Of Contents
- Cover
- Title Page
- Copyright Page
- Dedication
- Contents
- List of Figures and Tables
- Acknowledgements
- List of Abbreviations
- Introduction
- Terminological and editorial remarks
- Chapter 1 Constitutional foundations of the status of judges in the Federal Republic of Germany
- 1.1. Historical and legal contexts until 1949
- 1.1.1. The Kabinettsjustiz and the German judicial civil service
- 1.1.2. The constitution of the German Reich and the law on the judiciary
- 1.1.3. The Weimar Constitution
- 1.1.4. Courts in the Third Reich
- 1.1.5. The National Socialist legacy in the West German judiciary and its consequences
- 1.1.6. Fazit – the history of the German justice system in the twentieth century as an obligatory element of legal education
- 1.2. Constitutional rules of the exercise of judicial office under BL FRG of 1949
- 1.2.1. Historical context of the adoption of the BL FRG
- 1.2.2. The principle of democracy, the separation of powers, and the rule of law
- 1.2.3. Competence provisions – the judiciary in the German Federal State
- 1.3. Specific provisions of the BL FRG and their application in practice
- 1.3.1. Judicial monopoly
- 1.3.2. Constitutional principle of judicial independence (Article 97 BL FRG)
- 1.3.2.1. The substantive aspect of judicial independence
- 1.3.2.1.1. Did a violation of judicial independence by the federal government occur in 2021?
- 1.3.2.2. The personal aspect of judicial independence
- 1.3.3. Legal status of a judge in light of BL FRG provisions
- 1.3.3.1. Complaint regarding a judge’s violation of constitutional principles
- 1.3.4. Appointment of constitutional and federal court judges – legal and factual aspects
- 1.3.4.1. Selection of the Federal Constitutional Court judges
- 1.3.4.1.1. The political crisis caused by the election of three FCC judges in 2025
- 1.3.4.2. Selection of federal courts judges
- 1.3.4.2.1. A decision of the FCC of 20 September 2016 on selecting a federal judge (excerpt)
- 1.3.4.2.2. Selected practical aspects of the selection of federal court judges and presidents of federal courts
- 1.3.5. Selection of Länder courts judges in light of Article 98 (4) BL FRG
- 1.4. Summary
- Chapter 2 Judgement of the CJEU of 9 July 2020 in the case concerning the request for a preliminary ruling submitted by the Administrative Court in Wiesbaden (C-272/19). Is the referring court an independent and impartial tribunal?
- 2.1. Proceedings before the Administrative Court in Wiesbaden. The first question for a preliminary ruling concerning EU law provisions on the protection of personal data
- 2.2. Is the referring court an independent and impartial tribunal? Second question and its ratio decidendi
- 2.3. Legal status of judges in Hesse
- 2.3.1. Judicial independence
- 2.3.2. Irremovability and non-transferability of judges
- 2.3.3. Adequate application of civil service law to judges
- 2.3.4. Selection of Land judges
- 2.3.4.1. A Land judge appointed on probation
- 2.3.5. Practical aspect of elections of Land judges
- 2.3.6. Service supervision over Land judges
- 2.4. Judgement of the CJEU of 9 July 2020 on the preliminary ruling questions referred by the Administrative Court of Wiesbaden (C-272/19)
- 2.5. Summary
- Chapter 3 Request for a preliminary ruling of the Land Court in Erfurt (Thuringia) z 24 June 2020 (C-276/2020): Is the referring court an independent and impartial court or tribunal?
- 3.1. Proceedings before the Land Court in Erfurt. The first request for preliminary ruling – principle of effectiveness of EU law and civil law aspect
- 3.2. Is the referring court an independent and impartial tribunal? The second question for a preliminary ruling
- 3.2.1. Letter of the President of the Higher Land Court in Dresden of 9 April 2020 concerning the further conduct of the so-called VW proceedings
- 3.2.2. Commentary on the second preliminary ruling request
- 3.2.2.1. Judges membership in political parties
- 3.2.2.1.1. The case of judge J. Maier
- 3.3. Supplement to the request for a preliminary ruling of 22 April 2024
- 3.3.1. Three further questions – civil law aspect
- 3.3.2. Supplementary remarks concerning the question about the independence and impartiality of the Land Court in Erfurt of 22 April 2024
- 3.3.2.1. Commentary on supplementary remarks
- 3.4. Legal status of judges in Thuringia
- 3.4.1. Selection of Land court judges
- 3.4.2. Service assessment and promotion of a Land judge
- 3.5. Judges in the elections to the Landtag in Thuringia in 2024
- 3.6. Summary
- Chapter 4 Judgement of the CJEU of 27 May 2019 in the joined cases C-508/18 and C-82/19 PPU: Is a public prosecutor who, under national law, is directly or indirectly subject to potential instructions or directives from the Ministry of Justice sufficiently independent from the executive?
- 4.1. Proceedings before the Irish courts concerning the surrender of persons to the FRG on the basis of an EAW and preliminary questions regarding the independence of the German prosecution service
- 4.2. Commentary on requests for a preliminary ruling
- 4.3. Public Prosecutor’s Office in the German justice system
- 4.4. § 146 GVG – public prosecutors’ being bound by superiors’ instructions
- 4.5. § 147 GVG – service supervision over prosecutors and an external right of the minister of justice to issue instructions
- 4.5.1. Federal Minister of Justice H. Maas v. General Federal Prosecutor H. Range (2015)
- 4.5.2. Regulations of selected Länder concerning the right to issue instructions by Land justice ministers
- 4.5.2.1. Rhineland-Palatinate
- 4.5.2.2. Saxony
- 4.5.2.3. Schleswig-Holstein
- 4.5.2.4. Thuringia
- 4.6. The CJEU Judgement of 27 May 2019 in the joined cases C-508/18 and C-82/19
- 4.7. Commentary to the CJEU judgement of 27 May 2019
- 4.8. Inaction of the Federal Republic of Germany (2019–2025) regarding reform of constitutional provisions concerning the prosecution service
- 4.9. Summary
- Chapter 5 The 2025 Report of the European Commission on the Rule of Law in the Federal Republic of Germany
- 5.1. Legal basis for the monitoring of the rule of law by the European Commission
- 5.2. Constitutional aspects of oversight
- 5.3. Comments on the methodology of the report
- 5.4. The Commission’s 2025 report on the justice system of the FRG
- 5.5. Commentary to the Commission’s Report
- 5.6. Summary
- Conclusions
- Summary in selected theses
- Bibliography
- Commentaries, legal systems, monographs, and Chapters in monographs
- Articles in academic journals
- Press articles (including online editions)
- Articles, documents, and materials from online sources other than online press
- Legal acts and court decisions
- German legal acts
- Documents of German Federal and Länder Authorities
- Decisions of German courts
- Decisions of International Courts
- EU Acts
- Other EU documents
- Judgements of the Court of Justice of the European Union
Acknowledgements
The above book would not have been written without the constant encouragement from former Director of the Institute for Western Affairs in Poznań Justyna Schulz, PhD. Despite her linguistic and economic background, she has always stressed the importance of analysing legal and juridical issues in the Institute’s work.
I would like to express my special thanks to Prof Mariusz Załucki, PhD, Judge of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Poland, who devoted his time to reviewing the monograph, as well as to Editor Hanna Różanek for her tireless editorial work on the original Polish version of the book.
List of Abbreviations
BL FRG – Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany (Grundgesetz der Republik Deutschland, GG)
Bd. – Volume (Band)
BGBl. – Federal Official Gazette (Bundesgesetzblatt)
BT-Drucks – Bundestag printed paper (Bundestagsdrucksache)
CJEU – Court of Justice of the European Union
CFR EU – Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU
DAV – German Bar Association (Deutscher Anwaltsverein)
DRB – German Judges Association (Deutscher Richterbund)
DRiG – German Judges Act (Deutsches Richtergesetz)
EAW – European Arrest Warrant EAW
FAC – Federal Administrative Court (German Bundesverwaltungsgericht, BVerwG)
FCC – Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht, BVerfG)
FFC – Federal Financial Court (German Bundesfinanzhof, BFH)
FLC – Federal Labour Court (German Bundesarbeitsgericht, BAG)
FRG – Federal Republic of Germany
FSC – Federal Supreme Court (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH)
FSocC – Federal Social Court (German Bundessozialgericht, BSG)
GBl. – Official Gazette (Gesetzblatt)
GVG – Court Constitution Act (Gerichtsverfassungsgesetz)
Hrsg. – Editor (Herausgeber)
LG – Land Court (Landgericht)
OLG – Higher Land Court (Oberlandesgericht)
RGBl. – Reich Official Gazette (Reichsgesetzblatt)
18RiWG – Judicial Selection Act (Richterwahlgesetz)
TEU – Treaty of the European Union
TFEU – Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union
VG – Administrative Court (Verwaltungsgericht)
Introduction
This study is a result of over 4 years of analysing the diverse aspects of the operation of the courts in the Federal Republic of Germany, both at the federal level and in the Länder. This interest was sparked in part by the activity of EU institutions, primarily the European Commission and the Court of Justice of the EU, assessing Member States’ respect for the rule of law including the operation of the judiciary in Member States. Analysing the European Commission’s first report of 2020 dedicated specifically to the German judiciary,1 the author concluded that its thorough and complementary analysis would be in order, if only in terms of the legal status of judges in this Member State. An additional incentive was offered by the three cases submitted to the CJEU concerning the German justice system, discussed here.
The notion of the legal status of judges was adopted from German law, in particular federal constitutional law. Art. 98 (1) of the Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany (German Grundgesetz der Republik Deutschland, GG, hereinafter as the BL FRG)2 it titled “Rechtsstellung der Richter,” which translates as “the legal position” or “legal status” of judges. The author chose the latter notion and the plural form due to the solutions relevant in particular to federal and Länder judges, also covered by the above provision, as well as to the judges of the Federal Constitutional Court (German Bundesverfassungsgericht, BVerfG, hereinafter as FCC). A fundamental element of the legal status of judges in a democratic, social, and federal state of law (Art. 20 BL FRG) 20is their personal and material independence. However, a relevant analysis cannot focus solely on constitutional and statutory guarantees, both at the federal and Länder level. Moreover, the research objective includes the consideration of other legal provision providing complete judicial independence and their application. These are: provisions concerning the selection, appointment, official supervision, appraisal, and promotion of judges, their delegation to the executive, last but least their political activity. The choice of the above questions was not made in abstracto, but in relation to the references for a preliminary ruling submitted to the Court of Justice of the European Union (hereinafter as CJEU) by the Administrative Court (German Verwaltungsgericht, VG) in Wiesbaden:3 Can the referring court be considered an independent and impartial court within the meaning of Art. 267 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (hereinafter as TFEU) in conjunction with Art. 47 second paragraph of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union? (analysis of the reference for a preliminary ruling and of the CJEU ruling in Chapter 2) and by the Land Court in Erfurt (German Landgericht, LG):4 Is the referring court an independent and impartial court within the meaning of Art. 267 TFEU in conjunction with Art. 19 (1) third sentence TEU and Art. 47 second paragraph of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (hereinafter CFR EU)? Is the referring court an independent and impartial court within the meaning of Art. 267 TFEU in conjunction with Art. 19 (1) third sentence TEU and Art. 47 second paragraph of CFR EU? (analysis of the legal question in Chapter 3).
Further research objectives were to combine knowledge of the applicable legal provisions in the federal state, with a broader historical background, as well as the application of these provisions in Germany with regard to the administration of the courts primarily in terms of personnel by the executive. The essential line of the argument is thus based on four research objectives: 1. Examination of the historical and constitutional origins of the applicable provisions, 2. Analysis of the federal provisions: constitutional and statutory as well as analysis of the provisions of selected Länder, 3. Analysis 21of selected examples of the application of these provisions based on court decisions, documents of state authorities, as well as of associations of judges and prosecutors, legal doctrine, and media releases, 4. Evaluation of the above legal institutions by EU institutions: the Court of Justice of the EU and the European Commission.
Ad. 1. Chapter 1 contains a subsection 1.1. Historical and legal contexts prior to 1949, which enables a synthetic investigation of the development of German solutions of the justice system in terms of the legal status of a judge in the pre-Wilhelmine period, the Second Reich, the Weimar Republic, the Third Reich, national-socialist continuations in the justice system of the Federal Republic of Germany (hereinafter as the FRG), and their consequences for the democratic state of law. Subsection 1.2.1. discusses the historical context of the adoption of the Basic Law of the FRG. The author was faced with a considerable dilemma: whether to endeavour to present synthetically the major elements of the evolution of the German judiciary, while at the same time risking the accusation of superficiality and omission of important stages in it, or to abandon this part of the study altogether. The former option was chosen, in the knowledge of the risks involved, exacerbated by the fact that German scholarship, famous for its comprehensive discussions and commentaries, still lacks a comprehensive study on the history of the justice system. The decision for a historical outline was determined by the following considerations: the Court Constitution Act, still in force today (German Das Deutsche Gerichtsverfassungsgesetz, GVG), was adopted on 21 January 1877;5 other statues from the last decades of the nineteenth century have determined the relations between the judicial and the executive for the following 150 years of operation of the German justice system. These relationships, formed in the nineteenth century, trigger arguably the gravest concerns from the point of view of the guarantee of judicial independence. In contrast, the period from 1933 to 1945 was a time of unprecedented denial of judicial independence, supported by the majority of German judges. The topic of the judiciary’s complicity in the crimes of the Third Reich became the subject of broader scholarly, and partly public, debate only in the 1980s, when the first critical studies on the subject emerged, for example, I. Müller, Lawyers. 22The insurmountable past of our justice system” (German “Furchtbare Juristen. Die unbewältigte Vergangenheit unsere Justiz”).6 In this context, I would like to highlight Prof W. Kulesza’s invaluable contribution to the investigation of crimes, including judicial ones, committed in Poland by functionaries of the Third Reich.7 To my mind, one will not grasp the principles of operation of the German justice system without but a tangential familiarity with the historical and political context. In particular, the range of powers of the (federal and Länder ) Ministers of Justice to administer the courts, the position of court presidents, and the judges’ ability to engage in political activity are difficult to understand without a knowledge of the origins of these arrangements.
Ad. 2 and 3: In a study in the field of legal sciences, legal provisions are the primary object of analysis. This text pays special heed to them as analyses of the EU institutions are based on a narrowly defined legal state, which as a rule does not allow for a comprehensive and thus accurate assessment. For this reason, Chapters 2 through 4 will discuss not only the provisions of the BL of the FRG (Chapter 1, subsections 1.2 and 1.3 ), but also federal laws and the laws of the Länder, both at the level of the constitution and of the Länder laws. In this context, mention should also be made of sub-statutory regulations, whose validity is a feature of the German legal system with regard to systemically important issues, for example, the professional appraisal of judges and prosecutors, or the giving of official instructions to the latter by the Minister of Justice. Only by considering all these sources of law can a comprehensive assessment of German legal solutions be attempted. The analysis will not cover the law of all the sixteen Länder, as this would significantly exceed the scope of this study. Therefore, analysis is limited to two Länder, their choice conditioned on the references for a preliminary ruling submitted to the CJEU: C-272/19 – Land Hessia; C-276/2020 – Land Thuringia; regarding the legal status of the public prosecutor C-508/18 – Land Schleswig-Holstein and C-82/19 PPU – Land Saxony. Extensive excerpts 23from court decisions and documents are quoted in the study. In the case of German source texts, this is justified by the fact that access to them may be difficult, also for linguistic reasons.
Ad. 4. The above legal developments have been assessed twice by the CJEU (Chapters 2 and 3; in the latter case, a judgement was not delivered), as well as periodically by the European Commission under the mechanism of respect for the rule of law (Chapter 5, the 2025 Report8). To pursue this research objective, due attention was paid also to the CJEU ruling of 27 May 2019 in the case C-508/18 and C-82/19 PPU.9 Although the ruling does not address the legal status of a judge, it does deal with the issue of the independence of public prosecutors in Germany. The inclusion of this ruling in the study is triggered by the fact that it is the first ruling of the CJEU at all relating to the German judiciary in the context of the premise of the independence of a judicial authority within the meaning of Art. 6 (1) of the framework decision 2002/584/JHA of 13 June 2002 on the European arrest warrant and the surrender procedures between Member States (hereinafter the framework decision).10 In the case of the German public prosecutors’ offices, this was questioned in connection with the possibility of the Ministers of Justice giving instructions to prosecutors in individual cases. Second, issuing such instructions is a significant example of the link between the justice system and the executive and the implementation of the clerical model in the German judiciary. Third, the ruling launched a unique chain of rulings of CJEU on the operation of prosecution authority in general, even if the FRG did not change the relevant legal provisions until 2026. This state of affairs started in 1879, after the entry into force of § 146 and § 147 of the law on the court 24system, which provide for the prosecutor’s subordination to the minister of justice. This is an example of the continuity of the system’s organisation, the focus of Chapter 1. Last but not least the European Commission, within the framework of the structural judicial independence analyses safeguards relating to the functioning of national prosecution services in the EU.11 However, the introduction of one chapter on the independence of prosecutors is incidental and does not justify a change in the title of the study.
The structure of the study will enable the verification of the research hypothesis: the solutions adopted in Germany with regard to the legal status of judges, possibly prosecutors, are in line with the control standards adopted by the EU institutions and may constitute a reference model, in line with European standards, which could be taken into account in the process of judicial reform in other Member States (Conclusions).
Due to the adopted structure of the study, the dogmatic legal method and the historical legal method have been applied primarily. At the methodological level, the special features of the study include the exclusive use of original source texts, both in terms of normative acts, documents, the science of jurisprudence, as well as information on the practical aspects of the functioning of the judiciary in the political dimension, which comes from scholarly articles, associations of judges and prosecutors, and from the media. The analysis covers the specific solutions adopted in the German legal system and therefore does not limit itself to a description of these solutions, but includes a selection of federal and state laws, as well as examples of judgements, documents, or newspaper articles. The broad selection of source texts, which by no means exhausts all available German legal doctrine in the subject area, provides a profound insight into the legal system under discussion, a foreign system, which is at the same time very often presented as a point of reference or even as a model.
A in-depth insight into the German system of law and its application moreover implies an extensive consideration of the German language, which 25both shapes the system of law and the political reality of its application and expresses its centuries-old operating tradition. Indeed, a distinctive feature of the German state is its ability to create narratives through concepts that effectively, in line with the interests defined for a long time through the all-partisan compromise of the state, impact both domestic and international policy.12 Relevant to the study are no doubt terms such as the Legitimationskette (German chain of democratic legitimacy) Rechtsstaat (rule of law), Grundrechte (fundamental rights), or more recently Resilienz der Rechtsstaates (English resilience of the rule of law state) and wehrhafte Demokratie (militant democracy).
Accordingly, the study cites concepts, names of institutions and bodies, titles of instruments of law and documents in German. Some specific problems related to their translation are discussed in the subsection “Terminological and editorial remarks.”
Details
- Pages
- 386
- Publication Year
- 2026
- ISBN (PDF)
- 9783631948675
- ISBN (ePUB)
- 9783631953365
- ISBN (Hardcover)
- 9783631948668
- DOI
- 10.3726/b23816
- Language
- English
- Publication date
- 2026 (November)
- Keywords
- EU Germany judiciary rule of law CJEU European Commission independence of judges European values autonomy of prosecutors selection of judges German supreme courts
- Published
- Berlin, Bruxelles, Chennai, Lausanne, New York, Oxford, 2026. 208 pp., 5 fig. b/w, 4 tables.
- Product Safety
- Peter Lang Group AG