Beyond the Illiberal Order
Culture in a Globalized World
Summary
The book examines the cultural dimensions of globalization and the contemporary rise of illiberal tendencies around the world. It presents interdisciplinary essays, seen though postcolonial lens, dealing with cultural memory, literary narratives, colonial archives, problematic past, new media and the liberal arts, patriarchy and the female desire etc in the larger context of history of ideas.
It explores the process by which global modernity has shaped identities, imaginaries and generates anxieties across diverse cultural contexts. The book comes up with viable alternatives based on the neglected works of thinkers like Peter Kropotkin, Emma Goldman, M. N. Roy, Agnes Smedley, Mirra Alfassa, Rabindranath Tagore, Sri Aurobindo, Edward Said, Charles Taylor, Anthony Appiah and others for a post Illiberal, communitarian vision of the world.
Excerpt
Table Of Contents
- Cover
- Title Page
- Copyright Page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Foreword
- Preface
- Acknowledgements
- Publication Credits
- Introduction: Beyond the Illiberal Order – Culture in a Globalized World
- Chapter 1 Utopian Vistas: The Lost Legacy of Emma Goldman and M. N. Roy
- Chapter 2 Globalization and Cultural Memory
- Chapter 3 Culture Wars and the Claims of Multiculturalism
- Chapter 4 Battle Over Monuments: Dealing with Our Troubled Past
- Chapter 5 A Benevolent Empire? Colonial Gazetteers, and the Making of a Provincial Identity: The Case of L. S. S. O’Malley
- Chapter 6 Sri Aurobindo and the Problem of Self-Determination
- Chapter 7 Reclaiming the Indigenous: D. H. Lawrence and the Making of the American Counterculture
- Chapter 8 New Media and the Future of the Liberal Arts
- Chapter 9 The Forked Flame: D. H. Lawrence and Eco-Consciousness
- Chapter 10 Patriarchy, Female Desire and the Cyber World
- Chapter 11 Utopian Geographies: Agnes Smedley, the ‘Daughter of Earth’
- Chapter 12 Can Rhetoric Decide Authorship?: ‘The Problem of the Mahabharata’
- Chapter 13 Beyond the Colonial Gaze: Culture, Ideology and Translation Practice
- Chapter 14 Poetry in an Era of ChatGPT
- Conclusion
- Bibliography
- About the Author
- Index
Foreword
This elegant and eloquent book places itself in the best traditions of cultural criticism, written in a humanistic voice yet fully engaged with the best interlocutors in the social sciences, history and political sociology. Its main concern is about how to maintain critical cosmopolitanism, both in theory and in practice, in a time of illiberal authoritarianism, the erosion of artistic and academic freedom and regressive nationalism. This is a concern shared by many thinkers around the world and Prof. Mohanty brings an unusual Indian and postcolonial perspective to it.
Skillfully avoiding the twin temptations of cultural nihilism and political utopianism, the author offers an original look at how post-World War II norms of human rights, multiculturalism and transnational dialogue had the unexpected effect of sparking xenophobic nationalisms, ethnic fratricides and cultural parochialism in many parts of the world. Different forms of social violence also arose in the twenty-five years beginning with the War on Terror of 2001, and fostered a growing turn to authoritarian strong men, a worldwide impatience with democracy and an increase in suspicion towards immigrants, aliens and economic refugees. The cultural optimism of the latter decades of the twentieth century gave way to mutual suspicion and the hardening of cultural and political boundaries.
In this context, Prof. Mohanty turns towards a series of thinkers produced in the encounters of India and the West in the past century and a half: thinkers such as Sri Aurobindo, Mirra Alfassa, M. N. Roy, Rabindranath Tagore, Agnes Smedley and L. S. S. O’Malley, are some of the voices which Prof. Mohanty turns into resources for possible visions for the cultural future. This is an archival strategy which relies on what I have elsewhere termed ‘traces of the future’. Traces of the future are signs of efforts to generate alternatives in the midst of xiieveryday circumstances, to build possibilities, to find new things in the midst of the routines of reproduction. They are traces of possible futures. Not all such traces lead to finished, completed or successful projects or products or outcomes.
In this sense, what I am calling traces should not be confused with visions, plans, scenarios, predictions, projections and any other conscious efforts to envision the future, no more than science fiction can be seen as the central sign of utopian thinking. Traces of the future are unconscious, untheorized hints about future possibilities embedded in the midst of the daily life of ordinary people, and across a range of sites, practices and scenes. The challenge for the historian and the critic is how to recognize these moments or signs or hints in the archive of experience or the textual archive, without the benefit of hindsight about the moves towards the not-yet that succeed and those that fail.
Mohanty’s vignettes of his unusual cast of historical characters discern possibilities in their lives and voices which do not lead him to a single grand formula about the future. Rather, what he builds is a creative work of bricolage, an assemblage of the traces of hope in the humanistic archive with which to open doors for a communitarian, dialogic and socialist future.
Prof. Mohanty offers a way out of the predicament of a state-saturated world which cannot offer solidarity, dignity or community. His argument, and his mode of writing about the ethics of possibility, is a call to awakening of the capacity of cultural forms to revitalize the capacity to aspire beyond the ambit of the nation-state.
Prof. Arjun Appadurai
Berlin (Germany)
Emeritus Professor,
Media, Culture and Communication,
New York University.
May 2026
Preface
We must see the world as actors of the past did: through a foggy windshield, not a rear-view mirror.

If a historical sensibility is the temperament, then thinking historically is the practice. It is the active deployment of that sensibility as a set of tools to assess the world and make more informed choices. It is a distinct epistemology, one that offers a method for evaluating causality and agency, weighing competing narratives and navigating the dilemmas of decision-making without succumbing to what may be called ‘paralysis by analysis’. It offers not crystal ball, but a more sophisticated lens – a historical microscope – through which to see the present.
Francis J. Gavin1 (2025)
Francis Gavin’s timely reminder on the need for ‘thinking historically’, ‘through a foggy windshield’, one that avoids the peril of ‘paralysis by analysis’, may appear to be a self-evident fact, a shop-soiled truism. A closer look at past moments, movements and events would, however, reveal that our response to the past seems to gravitate towards easy, reductive binaries, the result of what Michel Foucault calls the ‘Enlightenment blackmail’2. Indeed, Western modernities that flow from the European Enlightenment tend to uphold perspectives in mutually exclusive terms, despite the merits of a more nuanced approach in cultural thinking.
While the Enlightenment claims may be contested in post-colonialism, they have paradoxically become the arbiter of ‘universal truths’. This is as true of scholarship as our approach to quotidian life that looks for facile and easy answers to complex problems of existence.
xivIt may therefore be useful at the outset to take a fresh look at the question central to the present project, namely, how to determine the contours of global cultures in an era of illiberal order. Such cultures, one may argue, are both the constituents and agents of the new wind flow in the global circuit. But the questions more to the point is: How do we explain the rise of illiberalism in the modern world? What social and ideological cross currents may be responsible for the current zeitgeist, the reign of regressive forces the world over? A puzzling development surely, given the fact that the last century witnessed the scourge of totalitarian regimes in Europe with Concentration and Extermination camps.
And finally, how can we carve out alternate cultural pathways beyond the illiberal order?

If were to visit some of the iconic narratives of globalization, viewed from a self-reflexive authorial point of view, scripted in the volume, Narratives of Globalization (Lee 2016), we are likely to encounter terms like ‘globalization and cultural homogenization’, ‘hybridity and the inventiveness of tradition’, ‘transculturation’, ‘localizing the global’, ‘language and interculturality’, ‘global moral economy’, ‘global security and international law’. These concepts and categories, rich in content and conceptualization, bring, in their wake, exciting experiences that cover a transnational and transcontinental terrain, they also symbolize the many facets of global studies, and the manner in which the global intersects powerfully with the local. Much of these and other aspects will be discussed, in detail, in rest of the book.
One of the most riveting accounts in Lee’s volume comes in the chapter entitled, ‘On Non-Places: Localizing the Global in Changi Airport’s Terminal 3, Singapore’. The author, Chriss Hudson, draws here effective parallels between the familiar [and nondescript] design and layout of international airports, from California to Caracas: the all too familiar prototype of airports as local malls: steel and concrete prefabricated structures that are mechanical and impersonal vis a vis the eye-catching spectacles witnessed in the terminals of Singapore’s Changi airport.
Hudson shows us insightfully that the local media such as The Strait Times, promotional literature, advertisements and billboards, both in the City State and in the airport zones, all ‘encourage the practice of dwelling and travelling at T 3’ and turn ‘the potential for travelling-in-dwelling and dwelling-in-travelling, into a lifestyle choice for families’3, (Hudson 2016: 42). In other words, Changi airport is ‘poised to become a place where Singaporeans choose to “hang out” on weekends-even if they are not leaving the country’.
Details
- Pages
- XXIV, 170
- Publication Year
- 2027
- ISBN (PDF)
- 9781805842736
- ISBN (ePUB)
- 9781805842743
- ISBN (Softcover)
- 9781805842729
- DOI
- 10.3726/b23943
- Language
- English
- Publication date
- 2026 (November)
- Keywords
- Globalization Homogenization Diversity Difference Universalism Particularism Hybridity Liminality Internationalism Cosmopolitanism Politics of representation Cultural Memory Liberalism Illiberalism Colonial Archives New Media Liberal Arts Patriarchy Female Desire Modernity Post-Modernity Late Capitalism Consumer Culture Multiculturalism History of Ideas Indigenous Socialism Communism Fascism Cold War Counter-Culture Utopia Dystopia Anarchism New Age Spirituality Communitarian living
- Published
- Chennai, Berlin, Bruxelles, Lausanne, New York, Oxford, 2026. xxiv, 170 pp.
- Product Safety
- Peter Lang Group AG